The best medium-sized wine lists in New York 2023

Here is the guide to the best wine places in New York with medium-sized wine lists – 200-600 different labels. These venues were all finalists in Star Wine List of the Year New York 2023. Check out all the venues and the winning wine lists!

  1. Phone: (212) 352-2300

    Address: 344 West 11th Street, New York

    Medium-Sized List of the Year New York 2023

  2. Phone: (212) 328-7880

    Address: 177 Prince Street, New York

    Medium-Sized List of the Year New York 2023

    Found yourself in New York craving some top Chinese comfort food and wine? This place in Soho ticks your boxes. Grab a place at the bar or a table and feast on surprising, tasty dishes like Peking duck benedict. The venue is buzzing with all kinds of guests and if you're into Spice Girls and George Michael – the music will make you happy too. The wine list features primarily organic, biodynamic and small-scale producers, many from Europe. At our latest visit the by the glass-wines came from Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Hungary, and the US. The house Riesling is from the Pfalz. The wine list...

  3. Phone: (212) 970-2200

    Address: 85 10th Avenue, New York

    By the Glass List of the Year New York 2023

    Melissa Rodriguez is no stranger to fine dining or 85 Tenth Avenue. Al Coro is the former Del Posto space, where Rodriguez was the executive chef. Now the team is back, and the food is better than ever. Al Coro offers three menus, one with five courses, and one with seven courses, as well as an a la carte menu. The menu, both food and wine pairings, change every six weeks and there is live music every night. “Al Coro is a restaurant built for celebrating,” and it certainly feels that way. The wine list has a lot to choose from, with over 600 references. While Italy is the focus, the list doe...

  4. Phone: (718) 254-0327

    Address: 465 Court Street, Brooklyn

    Medium-Sized List of the Year New York 2023

    An extremely homey and warm neighborhood spot. The food menu is focused on small, sharable plates that are very tasty, as is to be expected from the chefs behind the spots that line this block. Their other restaurants include: Frankie's 457 Spuntino and the brand-new F&F Pizzeria, which despite how bare bones it looks, serves one of the best slices anywhere. Long time Wine Director, John Burns Paterson IV (“JBP” to anyone who knows him) has amassed a truly impressive list, with pages of wines that will make your mouth water. European classics and a very respectable list of amazing West Coast...

  5. Phone: (917) 748-3248

    Address: 517 West 38th Street, New York

    Medium-Sized List of the Year New York 2023

    Recently re-opened after a long covid closure, Legacy Records is finally back and serving chef Ryan Hardy’s Italian inspired fare. Handmade pasta, raw bar and an incredible honey lacquered duck breast are not to be missed. In typical Delicious Hospitality fashion, the lighting is dim, the music is loud, and the decor is on point. Don’t forget to grab a cocktail at Ada’s Place upstairs before or after your meal. There’s Tarragona Chartreuse waiting for you… The wine list focuses heavily on French and Italian wine, but there is a smattering of wines from all over the world. Due to covid closure...

  6. Phone: +1 (929) 398-5433

    Address: 506 LaGuardia Place, New York

    Medium-Sized List of the Year New York 2023

  7. Phone: +1 (212) 254-3500

    Address: 89 South Street, Pier 17, New York

    Medium-Sized List of the Year New York 2023

  8. Phone: (646) 476-5420

    Address: 1 5th Avenue, New York

    Medium-Sized List of the Year New York 2023